Shan's Spark: Electrolytes: Fad or Fact?

Tips from Shan · Shan Charles · November 18, 2026

Those neon hydration packets are everywhere. According to market research firm Circana, Americans spent about $1.5 billion on powdered hydration mixes in 2024. So is it a fad, or is there something to it?

Shan's Verdict: Real Science, Loud Marketing

Electrolytes like sodium and potassium keep your muscles and nerves working, so they're no fad. The "you're chronically dehydrated, buy a packet" pitch is. One sports nutritionist calls that claim "probably an overstatement," and says plain water is enough for most people.

Who at The J Could Use Them

The rule of thumb: electrolytes earn their keep when you sweat hard for about two hours or more. Here's how that shakes out at The J.

Pickleball and tennis. Your best candidates. A long tournament day or a string of matches outside in the heat is exactly when sodium runs low. A quick hit before work? Water is fine.

Dance. Same two-hour test. Long rehearsals and recital weekends count; a regular class doesn't.

Group fitness and personal training. Most sessions run 30 to 60 minutes, and regular food covers it. The exception is heavy sweaters, who can lose anywhere from 200 to 1,800 mg of sodium per liter. Salt streaks on your shirt? That's you.

Swimmers. A normal lap swim doesn't call for a packet. Water and a post-swim snack will do.

Active agers. Water and balanced meals are enough for most. Read labels (sodium varies up to five times between products, and large amounts of potassium can be dangerous) and check with your doctor first if you have kidney or heart concerns.

The Easy Swap

A banana, a cup of yogurt, or a handful of nuts does the job of most packets. Here's where to find each one:

  • Potassium: bananas, potatoes, avocado, beans
  • Magnesium: pumpkin seeds, almonds, spinach
  • Calcium: yogurt, milk, kefir, kale
  • Sodium: your regular meals, plus olives, pickles, or soup

After a long match or rehearsal, try a banana with salted nuts, or a baked potato with a pinch of salt. Coconut water is better for recovery than mid-workout, since it has more potassium than sodium. Save the powder for the long, sweaty days.

Your Move

Before you reach for a packet, ask: Am I about to sweat for two hours? If not, grab water and a snack.

Shan's Final Verdict

I'm pro electrolytes, but only once you understand them. They're a tool, not a game changer. Know what they do, know when you've sweated enough to need them, and then use them on purpose.

Understand first, then sip.

About the author

Shan CharlesTips from Shan

More From The J

Programs, events, and everything happening on campus.

What Are You Looking for at The J?

Ask in plain language, pick a quick filter, or open the calendar. Every program and event at The J is in here.